Vincenzo's Convenient Elegance

Reviews

• JR

  Jennifer Roose

  4 days ago
  5.0
  My daughter did not want a cake for her recent birthday, she wanted tiramisu. I called several places around Columbus, with not much success. I called Vincenzo's on the advice of a friend, not only were they amazingly kind, and accommodating, but also knowledgeable in their product. They did tell me that they order it from a supplier but that it is good. Well, I'm here to tell you, they were not wrong!!! Also, when my husband picked it up, he bought me some of their chocolate canolis. As a former East Coast resident, Ohio canolis can be hit or miss. Theirs not only was a hit, it was a home run of a hit!! I am looking forward to trying some more of their lovely options. Thanks Vincenzo's! You made my kiddos birthday tiramisu a hit!!!
• BW

  Brandi Weaver

  Oct 27, 2025
  3.0
  I was very disappointed when I went in. It's very small and cramped. What was worse is they had food sitting out uncovered and un refrigerated. I paid $15.58 for 4 italian sausages that were over cooked and dried out. I paid around the same for a medium container of what I was told were marinated mushrooms. They were sautéed not marinated. I did not taste any seasoning on them. The rosemary sea salt bread was tasty but not worth $10 a loaf. I will probably not return.
• MG

  Mike Gabriel

  Oct 24, 2025
  5.0
  I’m in heaven right now. I just left Vincenzo‘s and devoured a sausage and peppers calzone and started working on the Italian beef calzone (slices of the calzones that is), and I think I’m gonna need a cigarette after this. I can’t believe I grew up in Columbus and have lived here for a total of about 45 years and I’ve never walked through these doors. I have been in the Trader Joe’s next-door multiple times and have driven by while somebody was cooking their Italian sausage on a grill right outside the door and I never had the sense to stop by and partake. Don’t make the same mistake I did! Get in here right away and try this calzone or some Italian sausage or lasagna or take home a loaf of their amazing looking fresh baked bread. I’m sure it’s all delicious. I’ll be coming back many times in the future, and I’ll definitely be taking home a loaf of bread or two. I just can’t believe I’m just now trying this.🤦‍♂️ also, ask questions because I didn’t see any cannoli, but they sell them to order and I have one of those to enjoy once I recover from the calzone experience. Thank you you too the nice man who helped me out and sliced me off a couple pieces of calzone and filled the cannoli for me. You definitely made my day, and I will be back. Vincenzo’s is outstanding!
• JK

  Jaquee K

  Oct 23, 2025
  5.0
  I stopped by Vincenzo’s just after one — the kind of Italian spot that feels like walking into someone’s kitchen. The smell of warm bread and melted cheese filled the air. I came for the Mushroom Calzone, baked until the crust turns golden and slightly smoky. Inside, the mushrooms were juicy, full of that charred, earthy aroma that makes you pause for a moment before the next bite. The staff split each dish for us without being asked — a small gesture that made the meal feel thoughtful and real. Vincenzo’s isn’t fancy. It’s comfort, care, and the quiet kind of joy that stays with you long after you’ve left.
• KS

  Kathy Sullivan

  Oct 16, 2025
  2.0
  My first time here because it looked so delicious in videos I saw . My first impression was a sign on the front door saying they were out of sandwiches . It’s 4:10 on a Wednesday. I walk in and it smelled absolutely delicious in there but the store looked very dirty as far as the floors and just the general look . I picked up two nice size manicotti rolls as Ive been dying for some delicious real homemade Italian manicotti . I got some extra sauce and that came to $19!!! Then I was dying for some delicious real homemade bread with my meal but when I asked about buying slices or a half of roll the owner stepped in and said NO you’ll have to buy a whole loaf . They had no samples and didn’t budge when it came to make sure I had some bread with my manicotti. I expressed my disappointment but he didn’t care . I was informed they sell dinner rolls but were ALSO out of those too . Would the owner have gone bankrupt if he threw a half of loaf with my Order and maybe charged me for half . But NO I was shutdown pretty quick . The manicotti was extremely disappointing. Fresh but bland , definitely needed some more spices also in the sauce . The manicotti was a waste of money I’m not even gonna eat that second one I spent almost $10 on as 2 we’re $19.. horrid piece of pasta . I’m from the east coast and I guess after 25 years in Ohio I should know nothing is authentic Italian here . Greedy customer service from the owner, dirty store . Huge disappointment and I’m still on the hunt for some delicious manicotti … Out of sandwiches and rolls by 4:10 too is inexcusable.. and so is your cold customer service