Tesoro

4.5
453 reviews

About

Italian Restaurant

Location

Tesoro
967 Old Country Rd, Westbury, NY
11590, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.5
453 reviews
5 stars
343
4 stars
57
3 stars
20
2 stars
11
1 star
22

What are people saying?

AI-generated from customer reviews

Service Quality

Customers frequently praised the attentive and friendly service, with many mentioning specific staff members who enhanced their dining experience.

Food Quality

While many reviews highlighted excellent food, there were also complaints about inconsistency, with some dishes described as bland or poorly prepared.

Ambiance

The restaurant's atmosphere received positive feedback, being described as warm, inviting, and suitable for special occasions.

Halal Options

Several customers appreciated the availability of halal options, noting that the staff was knowledgeable about dietary restrictions.

Mixed Experiences

Some reviews indicated significant dissatisfaction with service and food quality during busy times or large gatherings, suggesting inconsistency in performance.
  • HT
    Harsh Vardhan Thusu
    2 days ago
    1.0
    Food was probably the worst I had on Long Island. We ordered the salmon Bianca, ribeye, risotto, eggplant rolattini. Salmon and risotto were uncooked and the fish had a really weird smell. We didn’t want to argue because we had a small baby so basically didn’t eat most of the food, paid the bill and left. I cannot recommend this place to anyone . I have had better Italian food from dominos and will recommend you stay away. I do want to add that service was good and servers were very nice.
  • SL
    Steve Ligator
    Oct 18, 2025
    5.0
    Took friend out for birthday.
  • SB
    Sajal B
    Sep 17, 2025
    5.0
    Definitely a must try ! Very hospitable staff , they were able to do substitute couple items and stuff . Food is partially Halal. Great Italian Restaurant in Westbury with nice ambiance.
  • AS
    Ann Schiraldi
    Sep 16, 2025
    2.0
    We went there for a get-together 10 people we had the back room our waiter Joe was wonderful, the bread on the table wasn’t that good,and very little,you order an entree,thats all you get and very little,,no side of pasta,or choice of salad,this was our first time there and my last,I will stick with MAMAS RESTAURANT,go home with leftovers,and a full belly,,
  • MP
    Marsha Petersburg
    Sep 11, 2025
    5.0
    We had an unveiling tribute to my mother-in-law here in a private room. Everything was perfection and they treated up like family!! They provided everything we requested. It was a great setting for family to gather and reflect. Thanks so much!