Seafood Island Bar & Grille

Reviews

• DM

  Daniel Mckamie

  3 days ago
  5.0
  Went here based on local recommendation and was well worth it. Could barely finish everything as they give you a ton of food and best prices around
• JV

  Ja Vee

  Oct 7, 2025
  1.0
  We went there for the first time late afternoon Sunday. We spoke to the manager Haley on the phone and she answered all of our questions so we thought we would try it. When we got there, we asked for Haley, but were told she had just gone on break. Asking the other manager when she would be back off break, I was told she would be back after 1 or 2 hours! I did not ask her name but she had two stone type piercings, one above here lip, and one below. I asked this manager if I could get a bun to go with my dinner. She said yes but I would be charged $4.00 for just the bun. She said "that is what I was told to charge for a bun by the owner" wow! We are both on strict food diets with zero fried foods. We decided to get the crab cake dinner, grilled, with 2 baked potatoes, and the other was the stuffed flounder, broiled, with 2 baked potatoes. After waiting 25-30 minutes, someone came out from the back and asked who ordered the stuffed flounder. He said they were out of the provolone cheese, but I could get American or cheddar. I chose cheddar. 15-20 minutes later, I received my dinner. My wife did not get hers yet. Not letting it get cold, I ate mine. About 30 minutes later, someone from the back comes out and informs her that they are out of baked potatoes. She replied NO, that is the only side I could eat. If I can't have a whole dinner, I want my money back! Another 15 minutes later, someone else comes out from the back and says "you need to choose something else. She said NO, I just want my money back. He responded with "I can't do that". Another 15 minutes later, another person comes out with what would have been her dinner, without the baked potatoes. She said NO, take it back I want my money back! 10 minutes later someone drops her money on the table and leaves. That is almost an hour after they brought out my dinner, unreal !! No apologies from anyone, at any time !!! We saw another guest sitting there who ordered take-out with baked potatoes also who said she was waiting for an hour already. It started out promising, but this place needs real adult help and management. Needless to say we will not be back, nor will we tell our friends to come here. Also, we never did get to speak to Haley.
• JS

  John Schildknecht

  Oct 5, 2025
  5.0
  My wife and I were in Jacksonville and decided to find dinner, we did a quick internet search for "Dinner near me" and then started scrolling. We each were scrolling and we both landed on Seafood Island Bar & Grill. I had the pick two with Mahi and jumbo shrimp, my wife had stuffed jumbo shrimp, stuffed with crab cake. We were BOTH elated with our dinner! The flavor and quantity were TOP SHELF! We will be back !!
• CH

  Chaia Harrell

  Oct 2, 2025
  3.0
  A little pricey for the portion size and quality of the food and beverages. Staff was polite but not very friendly. Utensils didn't appear to be clean.
• TB

  Tara B

  Sep 30, 2025
  5.0
  Family Night Out was spectacular. We had an awesome selection of food. The atmosphere post dinner was so nice and we walked in the San Marco area. Will definitely be back🤗