Sarah's on Central

Reviews

• NO

  Nathan Olaoluwa

  Oct 11, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered a takeout here and they said it’ll take 20mins, it took an hour just for two orders. That’s not even a problem. The entire order was nothing to write home about. They even forgot to put gravy on the biscuit and syrup for waffle. Their loaded potato soup tastes horrible like expired or something - definitely not edible. The food was terrible and a waste of money.
• NB

  Niki Bridges

  Oct 6, 2025
  5.0
  Very cute spot on the main street in Eureka. Food is fresh and delicious, with a good portion soze. Cocktails are yummy! Don't forget to get one of their amazing baked goods!
• KC

  Kim Connelly

  Sep 25, 2025
  5.0
  Breakfast was delicious and came out quickly. Service was friendly, my coffee cup was always full. Will be back to try lunch and dinner.
• JY

  Jena Yarbrough

  Sep 15, 2025
  5.0
  Service was slow. The waiter must have been new.
• AH

  Ashlie H

  Aug 27, 2025
  3.0
  I used to really love Sarah’s but lately it’s been really busy and loud. We aren’t able to make reservations, which is a big bummer, and the service has been a bit slow. The food also feels overpriced. I wish the hours were more consistent too. While they are posted on google (and that’s on me for not checking), I don’t want to check google every day to see their hours. Closing at 2pm, then 6pm, then 8 pm is hard to adjust to and can be really frustrating when you pull up and it’s closed because it’s not the specific day they are open late. I do understand a lot of that is on me, but consistency in hours would go a long way to ensure continued business.