Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

Reviews

• MK

  Michael Kramer

  Oct 14, 2025
  1.0
  I ordered a steak sub.Ask the girl, how long it would take?She said ten minutes twenty four minutes later.She asked to cook, is that steak sub done.He said i'm taking it out now as I can visually watch him.Texting on his phone for about three more minutes.He then took it out, cut it, wrapped it, and she brought it to me.I left got it, my truck as I was now late to go to my call and was going to eat on the way.I unwrapped it and I wanted to bite it.It was so burned, wasn't even edible
• SC

  Shane Cockle

  Oct 6, 2025
  5.0
  Plenty of selections to choose from. Great place to eat.
• AG

  Amy Green

  Aug 25, 2025
  5.0
  Service was exemplary. Pizza was light on sauce when standard pizza ordered. Crust was perfect.
• BB

  Bonquisha

  Aug 25, 2025
  3.0
  We come here/order p/u often. The food is consistently good. (Best Salvatore’s in the area, imo). The bar area is often really, really loud for late afternoon/early dinner. This makes inside dining almost impossible sometimes. If you have kids, bring ear plugs so they don’t hear the foul language/banter being shouted across the bar. Generally the service is on point. However, there are 2 bartenders that are notoriously slow and definitely prioritize friends/regulars. We usually experience this on Thursday nights and Sunday afternoons. Unfortunately there are no other servers/wait staff. Please add a changing table to your bathrooms. We don’t love having to change our kiddo in the only one that has a flat surface— a pleather bench. Take out: 5/5 Dining in: 2/5
• EG

  Eric Guittard

  Aug 25, 2025
  1.0
  Ordered chicken wings waited 30minutes before they told me they lost my ticket and I had to wait an additional 30minutes so I got it to go. Just to find out they put wrong sauce on it so I went without lunch. I went back following week asked if I could get compd for my order and they wouldn't. I'm a regular there and was going twice a week for at least a year and bringing other people from work. Bad Business on there part I won't be going back