Roth Cadillac

4.2
131 reviews

About

Cadillac DealerCar DealerAudi DealerAuto Body ShopUsed Car DealerAuto Parts StoreAuto Repair Shop
Discover local, personalized service at Roth Cadillac in Erie, PA, the world's oldest Cadillac dealership. Our team of certified EV technicians and extensive selection of new and pre-owned Cadillac models ensure an enjoyable buying experience. We're equipped with EV chargers, commercial service capabilities and offer convenient shuttle and loaner car services. Plus, enjoy peace of mind with our extended warranty options. Schedule Cadillac service or a test-drive in Erie and learn why PA Cadillac enthusiasts choose Roth Cadillac.

Details

  • Credit cardAvailable
  • DebitAvailable
  • Accepts checksAvailable

Location

Roth Cadillac
5711 Peach St, Erie, PA
16509, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.2
131 reviews
5 stars
94
4 stars
9
3 stars
5
2 stars
5
1 star
18

What are people saying?

AI-generated from customer reviews

Customer Service

Feedback indicates a mix of experiences with customer service, with some praising the staff for being friendly and helpful, while others report unprofessional behavior and poor communication.

Sales Experience

Many customers had positive experiences with the sales team, highlighting professionalism and a no-pressure approach, although some reported feeling undervalued or ignored.

Service Department

The service department received significant criticism for poor communication, delays in repairs, and inconsistent quality of work, with some customers expressing frustration over unresolved issues.

Collision Center

The collision center received positive remarks for quality repairs and timely service, with customers appreciating the thoroughness and cleanliness of their vehicles post-service.

Overall Satisfaction

Overall, experiences vary widely, with some customers expressing high satisfaction and loyalty, while others warn against potential issues with service and transparency.
  • SP
    Shaun Powell
    Oct 27, 2025
    1.0
    Horrible. Not even worth a 1 star. No communication, promises of call back which are never received. Megan was awful. Do not do business here.
  • SS
    Sage
    Oct 8, 2025
    1.0
    Sorry, but do not recommend. 🫤
  • ND
    Nicole D'Abo
    Oct 6, 2025
    1.0
    My insurance sent my vehicle here against my best judgment.I have heard some pretty bad stories about this ROTH CADILLAC, But I figured my insurance knew best. I WAS WRONG. I SPENT MY MORNING ON THE PHONE BEING YELLED AT BY AN ANGRY GENTLEMAN BY THE NAME OF GENE.. He said he was the manager. First, GENE told me I was lying about what one of his employees told me was done (repairs) to my vehicle.. Then he told me my vehicle "had been sitting for a very long time [at my home]".. Both things are false. Thank goodness I record everything! Bottom line is, the exact issue I took my vehicle in for, $500 later, is the same issue I'm STILL having today (& some new ones). Incorrect diagnoses happen, mistakes happen and that is ABSOLUTELY OKAY, but being unprofessional, disrespectful, immature and yelling at/over a PAYING customer is ABSOLUTELY UNACCEPTABLE. Our phone conversation ended with GENE telling me that, "Just to look at [my] vehicle [again], will be a $160.00 an hour..." and that I should "take [my] car to a smaller repair shop to be looked at."..So basically refusing to look at my car and see if he made a mistake or [if the problem had not been repaired properly] correct their mistake..NOPE! ROTH CADILLAC just took the money and ran. If you go here JUST KNOW THAT THEY ARE 100% CORRECT, 100% OF THE TIME, ON 100% OF THE VEHICLES THEY WORK ON, AND YOU BETTER NOT QUESTION THAT! However, if you have quality insurance (AS I DO), LET MINE AND MANY OTHER ONE 🌟 REVIEWS BE A CAUTIONARY TALE FOR YOU AND Do not waste it on this ROTH CADILLAC.
  • JB
    Jeff Barber
    Jul 11, 2025
    5.0
    Friendly and helpful Little bit of inflation since this ad!
  • JY
    Jesse Yates
    Jul 3, 2025
    5.0
    Roth Cadillac does it right. I just purchased a 3yr lease on a 2025 LYRIQ and Megan Stokes and Jim Paulson could not have been better to deal with. There was no pressure, they were EXTREMELY responsive and went above and beyond to get me not only in the exact car I wanted, but at an excellent price. Paper work was a breeze with finance and they made it quick because I had my 15 month daughter with me. Really appreciate the support I received at delivery and Megan showing me all the features. I couldn’t be more pleased and feel this could be the beginning of a long relationship with Roth Cadillac in Erie, Pa. If I could give 6 stars I would! Highly recommend anyone looking for a new or used car to go to Roth. I am confident they will take care of you and provide a customer experience that makes you feel valued.