Puerto Vallarta Restaurant

4.3
1564 reviews

About

Mexican RestaurantRestaurantTaco RestaurantBeer Garden
At our Mexican restaurant in New Albany, IN, we craft every meal with fresh ingredients so we can ensure the richest flavors. We're also not stingy with our portions and do everything we can to ensure you're well-fed when you dine with us. For over eight years, we've provided an upscale, quality dining experience where you can sit, relax, and enjoy. Our servers are quick on their feet, professional, and friendly. We also featured a large assortment of drinking options, such as domestic beers, margaritas, and much more. Visit Puerto Vallarta Restaurant for your next meal, and contact us for more information!

Details

  • Dine-inAvailable
  • DeliveryNot available
  • TakeoutAvailable
  • Accepts reservationsNot available

Location

Puerto Vallarta Restaurant
4214 Charlestown Rd, New Albany, IN
47150, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.3
1,564 reviews
5 stars
944
4 stars
350
3 stars
121
2 stars
56
1 star
93
  • LB
    Logan Blanton
    5 days ago
    1.0
    My meal and my wife’s meal were both over made with cilantro. We kindly asked if they could remake it with out it and they told me I had to pay for both extra meals including the two we did not eat/like. Ended up arguing to get our meals taken off as we both took 1 bite. Poor management
  • GG
    Grace
    Oct 4, 2025
    5.0
    I'm very satisfied with my visit! Me, Husband, and three kiddos came in last night and the food was amazing! My husband got the carne asada and the meat was huge. He lovess a good big slab of meet for dinner . Almost just as much as me 😉. Anywho i'm very satisfied with my visit 10/10 recommend. I WILL BE BACK.
  • AL
    A L
    Aug 31, 2025
    1.0
    Bait and switch Added an extra $12 for no reason And $3.00 for jalapeños
  • AF
    Amanda Ferguson
    Aug 29, 2025
    1.0
    As soon as we order the food it was out a few minutes later. The food came out super fast. We thought we try a new place other than El nopal. That was a mistake. The queso was like water I did my chip in it brought the chip out there was nothing on my chip. There is three people who ordered. The food was not good. Did we complained or said anything back no. Just paid and left People say they love this place. I don't see how.
  • BJ
    Blue Jay
    Aug 22, 2025
    1.0
    I've been here twice before 2-3yrs ago & was delicious. Went for lunch today while in the area & got a burrito that spose to had shrimp steak & chicken with chs sauce. I received just a spot of chs sauce, just literally 1 piece of shrimp & tortilla was cardboard not even heated properly. Didn't order a full meal, just a burrito & a tea. They charged me $28 & waiter said I can wait for a manager another 30min to get there to discuss the issues smh. No wonder the place was empty. Watery queso that slides off like water what little they give & lowest quality cook in the kitchen. The cashiers was very nice helped atleast take off $5. I won't be back. What a waste