America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!
Customers frequently praised the pizza for being delicious and fresh, especially the buffet options.
Customer Service
While many reviews highlighted friendly and helpful staff, there were notable complaints about rude service from some employees.
Buffet Experience
The buffet was generally well-received, with a good variety of pizzas and other items, though some customers reported issues with food temperature and availability.
Family Atmosphere
The restaurant is recognized as a family-friendly place, often visited by families and praised for its welcoming environment.
Delivery Issues
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with delivery service, citing delays and poor food quality upon arrival.
TT
Tara Torres
Oct 31, 2025
5.0
Ordered via Door Dash. Pizza and calzone were delivered hot and fresh. Will definitely be in to try the buffet.
EG
Enoch Gattenby
Oct 12, 2025
5.0
Recently ate at the restaurant. The chili that was put out on the buffet was grub!!! My kids love coming here. The staff is always friendly. They'll make any ki d of pizza you want.
AG
Amberly Gaskin
Aug 20, 2025
1.0
I will never ever eat at the buffet at pizza inn again due to the fact I grabbed my own slice of pizza with my hand without touching any other piece as an employee politely told me to use the tongs because he now had to throw the entire pizza out and asked loudly if I wanted more slices since I used my hand instead of tongs to take my slice of pizza. I declined due to embarrassment and will never ever allow anyone to ever belittle me ever again….I suggest to the owner that you teach your employees how to treat their patrons with respect and dignity and never treat a human being or any other creature as if they are nasty and gross. Suggestion
Customer service skills are definitely needed for pizza inn employees in Muskogee ok.
Btw I would be more worried about the flies landing in the food than me touching my own slice of pizza I have never been more embarrassed that I want to cry.
The waitress was lovely
Thank you
LG
lillian grace
Aug 16, 2025
5.0
i love this place. yummy pizza and very friendly staff. :)
JL
Jacob Lester
Aug 4, 2025
5.0
Pizza is the best in muskogee. They have the best thin crust pizza of all flavors. Pepperoni, alpine, BBQ chicken, taco, pepperoni and jalapeño. It is buffet but you can ask for a certain pizza for the buffet