Pie95 Pizza

Reviews

• HP

  Halie Pullen

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Hubby and I ordered the carnivore pie and enjoyed the outdoor patio. The staff recommended we top it with hot honey, and that was definitely a good call. The pizza came out hot and fast, and it was delicious. We chatted with the owner on our way out, who was a super nice guy. We're here visiting Jax from Tallahassee, but definitely adding this place to our list of favorite Jax places, since we usually come once or twice a year.
• MS

  Michael Sharp

  5 days ago
  5.0
  Excellent, friendly service and amazing food, as always! Well done Pie95!!
• AB

  Alex Baker

  Oct 1, 2025
  5.0
  Service was great, as usual. Pizzas are absolutely authentic to Italy with simple but delicious flavorings. My wife is from Naples and highly recommends "Pie 95" and all it's offerings. Alex Baker
• MT

  M Thomas

  Sep 27, 2025
  5.0
  The staff is awesome! The owner was in the kitchen training! Many options made it hard to decide what to order, so we decided on Korean flavor wings, The Pepperoni, added sausage, and the arugula salad with pine nuts, parmesan cheese and Ceasar dressing. One of the staff suggested we use the Mike's Hot Honey and that took it the next level! My husband & I have lived just outside of New York city and Houston (all kinds of great food there) which gave us plenty of chances of eating great pizza. Pie95 Pizza 🍕 satisfied our taste buds for great pizza. Thank you Pie95, we will be back! Sorry no photos cause we were too hungry and the food was too good.
• NS

  Nick Saam

  Sep 24, 2025
  5.0
  Best pizza in north Florida. Not even close. Been eating pizza here for 7 years. Tonight is my last visit only because we’re moving. A few years ago, Pie 95 planned to launch a product they could ship - partially baked and frozen pizza you finish in the oven at home. I was a tester for that product. We cooked 10 or so at home, each almost as delicious as fresh from the restaurant. In this reviewers opinion, Pie 95 should launch this product and ship to me in Colorado. Thanks for all the calories Evan! Ship them to me now.