Penny's Pizza

Reviews

• HS

  Hyman Stallings

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Pizza’s fire, prices are fair, and the staff is very nice. Highly recommend if you want quality ingredients. Only thing—they gotta open Sundays. Perfect game day spot, they’re missing out.
• SD

  Sasha Datsyk

  1 day ago
  5.0
  Best comfort pizza In town. ask for jalepenos on your pep. also really creamy ranch dressing.. 10/10
• KJ

  Kylee Jones

  4 days ago
  2.0
  I’m sure the pizza here is great, but my husband ordered one for takeout today and when he arrived the worker told him the pizza was burnt so it was on the house. My husband could also tell the pizza was cold so instead of just making a new pizza they left the burnt one out just sitting. Free food is nice but we would have gladly just paid for an unburnt pizza.
• NS

  Nico Seperas

  Oct 15, 2025
  5.0
  First time ordering! So excited. Everyone in the neighbourhood says it’s amazing! The pizza was amazing. Perfection. The sauce especially was so flavourful. Real Italian. Real good! Definitely going back and soon!
• TK

  Teresa Knowles

  Oct 4, 2025
  1.0
  Our first visit went well, the pizza is pretty good in a nostalgic way. It's not going to win any awards but it reminds me of the type of pizza you'd eat as a kid in the early 2000's. Decent, tavern-style pizza. We even made a big order for a birthday party. Today, though, I had a terrible experience. As soon as I walked in, the 3yo needed to go to the bathroom. I knew it was through a hallway that is next to the kitchen. A little odd, but fine. I called out "hey, just using the restroom, will be back to order", hurried there, realized we needed a code and came back for it. Before we could step inside again, an employee proceeded to chastise me for "barging into a restaurant and walking through the kitchen". He said we (a 4'11 woman with 2 small kids) scared him, that he didn't know who had just walked in and that he could get in trouble for that. I get being a little startled (we were rushing to avoid an accident and maybe he didn't hear me), but the lecture was unnecessary and off-putting. It felt confrontational and like a microaggression. I doubt he would have confronted a white dude like that. I used to be a server and can’t imagine lecturing a guest that way. We left and went to Life of Pie instead, which has better pizza, friendlier staff and a great happy hour. We probably won't be back.