Patty Shack

Reviews

• RD

  Robert Daher

  Oct 16, 2025
  5.0
  An Absolute Must-Visit: Patty Shack is a Milwaukee Gem! I recently had the pleasure of dining at the Patty Shack in Milwaukee, and I can't stop thinking about the experience—it was truly outstanding from start to finish. If you're looking for a new favorite burger spot, look no further. Exceptional Service and Impeccable Cleanliness First off, the service was awesome. The staff was incredibly welcoming, attentive, and genuinely seemed to enjoy their jobs. The facility itself was very clean. It's clear the Patty Shack takes pride in its appearance, making for a comfortable and pleasant dining environment. The Burger That Brought Me Back.... I'm from Racine, the burger at Patty Shack took me right back to a nostalgic family favorite, Pinochio's (for those unfamiliar, was a legendary spot). The quality, the perfect sear, the flavor profile—it was..... nostalgic, the perfect burger that hit all the right notes. It's rare to find a burger that can evoke that kind of memory and flavor, but the Patty Shack absolutely nailed it. Final Verdict The Patty Shack, with its combination of great service, a spotlessly clean facility, and a truly incredible, nostalgic burger, this place is an absolute winner. Do yourself a favor and make the trip—you won't regret it!
• PL

  Peter Van Lone

  Oct 13, 2025
  5.0
  Love these burgers! One option I'd love to see are more cheese choices - blue cheese, for example. This is Wisconsin - lots of great choices! Cheddar, Swiss Gouda... Other than that, perfect!
• GJ

  Gregory Jordan

  Oct 4, 2025
  3.0
  Long wait so didn't get to order. People in line were said to have been waiting for an hour. Food must be very good for that commitment. I will try again another day.
• PT

  Pecan Tan

  Oct 1, 2025
  2.0
  I ordered a bacon cheese burger single the bacon was bacon crumbles the patty was crispy around the edges the sandwich was $9.00 no fries I did get the fry sauce to try at home the fry sauce garbage I will try them again but I will let them know I want my cheeseburger to look like the pic on their website I am not happy about this and the onions were diced medium size very subpar sandwich u might as well go to Wendy's at least the sandwich will be hot
• 11

  1badruckus

  Sep 25, 2025
  5.0
  In Milwaukee and was looking for a burger place. Found the Patty Shack in the BayView neighborhood. Located in a modern unassuming storefront this restaurant makes my list. The burgers are hand formed and are rather delicious. No frozen grey patties here. The fries were good. Service was excellent and quite fast. The dining area itself was clean. There is off street parking. I would definitely go back.