Papa's New York Diner

Reviews

• MK

  Malachi Keasler

  3 days ago
  1.0
  I I ordered $27.30 worth of food at around one or 2 o’clock in the morning in May. I have been trying to get a refund as they have said to go through my card every time. I was craving breakfast food so it was the only place that was open that was serving breakfast. I go there for the first time I order my food I wait for 20 to 30 minutes go back in. She says that they’re still working on it. 10 minutes later for cop cars pull up and I’m standing outside and they told me to come over to my car and I don’t have the keys to my car and they they try to do a full sobriety test and then they end up arresting me costing me 10,000 dollars. I still didn’t get the food. I have went to the restaurant 3 to 4 times as they told me too, and I never got the food. I never got a reimbursement. They do not do gift cards since I did Apple Pay. They could not reimburse it to the card bc of apple pay. They’re under new ownership and there is a new manager.. I’ll come back one day when I’m hungry and they didn’t honor that as well. I offered the food to the police or for them to give to the homeless, but she never started making it. I didn’t wanna leave a bad review, but all my friends have been have gone here so far and have had similar experiences so they will also stated to leave reviews on bad service, horrible food, theft. This is an easy fix and not something to be rude about when I come in with no anger. I don’t know how this restaurant is going to stay stable, a horrible business, horrible people, and horrible blonde manager. Carol my cashier doesn’t even work there anymore that did this. I was also the only person in the restaurant. If your worried about me and want to ruin my career tell me to call a friend if you think i’m going to drive.
• CO

  Christian Ortiz

  4 days ago
  3.0
  The food was very good, but the waitress's service was terrible. Maybe she was having a bad day from the beginning, she had a bad attitude towards us. She threw the straws on the table and the coffees too. Then she made a mistake with our orders and when I tried to tell her she was wrong she said that's what they ordered. We had to exchange plates so we could eat what we ordered. For that reason, I considered not leaving tips, but I still left the change, which was like 3 dollars, and I bet she didn't mind when she came out to the parking lot to complain that I left her three dollars. If she had had a better attitude and service, she would have earned a good tip. Because I think the tip is based on the service we received.
• SD

  Seena Danka

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Very cute diner. Been going here since 23’ and the entire look of the place is very cozy and a nice hangout spot with my friends. Food is amazing and they have DISCO FRIES!! nice place to grab a bite and romanticize your life, lol.
• SW

  Stephan Wyland

  Oct 15, 2025
  4.0
  Cheesecake. Every once in a while you find that cheesecake that has a really strong cheesecake flavor, but it's not overwhelmed by that cheese flavor. Unfortunately that usually means that you don't know that you're really having cheesecake. This place does it right, you know it's cheese you know it's cheesecake, and it was really quite spectacular. I'm just for nothing, the living room is pretty damn good
• SB

  Summer Buese

  Oct 14, 2025
  5.0
  Absolutely enjoyed the service I received by Dave this morning. He was very attentive along with an inviting way about him which made the experience here even better. The food came out fast & was amazing. 10/10 recommend