Olive Cart

Reviews

• BL

  Beth Loftus

  Oct 16, 2025
  5.0
  Best dressing combo. Their information boards when I looked at the white balsamic was to pair with Key Lime Avocado Oil. I can’t even explain how good this is. I don’t even like salad really but I eat it to have this dressing. Also purchased yummy dark balsamic. Totally need to go back and figure out the best olive oil! So many choices.
• EE

  E

  Aug 27, 2025
  5.0
  I had a fantastic experience at Olive Cart! The selection of olive oils and balsamics was truly impressive, with a huge variety to choose from. The employee was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, making the visit even more enjoyable. Sampling the diverse flavors was a highlight—a fun and unique experience for sure. Highly recommend stopping by to explore their amazing range.
• MS

  Mai Sahay

  Jul 2, 2025
  5.0
  We live in Chicago suburb, but we love to go here when we're heading to Michigan to visit family. We buy all our Balsamic vinegars from here. There are places here in Chicago locally but are not as good (too watery and expensive). Our favorite are the 25yrs aged South Haven Balsamic Vinegar which is really a Traditional Balsamic Vinegar and the Cranberry Pear Balsamic vinegar. Its nice and thick due to ageing. Despite being sourced from Italy, the price is reasonable. As a comparison I purchased a Traditional dark Balsamic Vinegar 200ml in Chicago for $16.95 which was sourced from Southern California and was watery compared to 250ml of the 25 year South Haven Traditional Dark Balsamic Vinegar for $18.95 which is nice and thick and sourced from Italy. The store is nice and service is very good. Keep it up!
• BA

  Betty A

  Aug 15, 2021
  5.0
  This place has the absolute best feta cheese stuffed olives! Everything we have tried has been so yummy.