New York Bagels N Bialys

Reviews

• KY

  Kari Yatkowski

  6 days ago
  1.0
  I order one seseme bagel with cream cheese. When I got home I had a soggy plain bagel with nothing on it in a plastic bag. This is a sorry excuse for taking First Watch out. Utterly disappointing. I will never go back.
• HC

  Harrison Crall

  6 days ago
  1.0
  Came here today to get my wife a simple toasted asiago bagel with cream cheese. Took them over 15 minutes to bring me my order and I was the only person waiting for a to go order. The only other people in the restaurant were 2 tables in the dining half of the restaurant with a maximum of 3 people at each table. When I finally get my order I’m walking out to the car and I realized that the bagel is cold. So I walk back in to ask them to warm it up. The girl at the counter decided to get off her phone and walks into the back for maybe 2 minutes and what she brings back is warm. But I unwrap the bagel and I get what you can see in the picture. An un toasted bagel with a glob of cream cheese. Again I waited over 15 minutes for this. And I also left a tip when I was paying for the bagel. It’s extremely frustrating to go somewhere to get something as simple as a toasted bagel and that can’t even be accomplished. Would not recommend
• DW

  David Weinberg

  Oct 11, 2025
  3.0
  Food was okay... The potato pancakes were very huge, but very dense. I've had this type of potato pancake elsewhere in AZ and choose not to eat there either. The blintzes were very disappointing. They were small squares so the three pieces you get equal one standard sized blintz (where you typically get two or three). The recipe was extremely wet. Not the usual consistency you would expect. The service was excellent. Attentive and personable. The atmosphere: they had the same sticky tables that First Watch (previous tenant) had. There was dried on ketchup on the salt shaker. We had high hopes which weren't met. I don't expect we'll be back.
• JP

  Jeff Peduto

  Oct 9, 2025
  5.0
  Our order was made perfectly! Exactly as expected which is not as common as it should be, lol. Taste, texture and assembly were perfect. It was takeout so my score on atmosphere was based on the fact that the place was empty - so not really a vote up or down. Service was good but staff were neither great nor poor - just doing their job.
• PW

  Paul Westhoff

  Oct 5, 2025
  5.0
  Everything we ordered for breakfast was of unbelievable quality !! Highly recommend! That green chilli and that cheese sauce on the side is Devine !!