McNay & Messick, CPA, PC

Reviews

• SM

  Sheryl Mickelson

  Jul 21, 2025
  1.0
  Avoid this firm. I met with Nathan in the summer of 2024 to amend our taxes. While the meeting itself went well, I had to follow up months later to get the work completed — and even then, it was done incorrectly. I dropped off our 2024 tax documents at the end of January 2025 and heard nothing back. After repeated calls and emails, I eventually learned (without any prior notice) that an extension had been filed on our behalf. Despite checking in regularly, I received no meaningful updates. By June 2025, I had to physically visit their new office location — which we were never informed about a move — to request the return of our business paperwork. Nathan handed them to me from a pile on the floor. The entire experience was disorganized, unprofessional, and extremely frustrating.
• CH

  Cole Hawkinson

  Apr 14, 2025
  1.0
  Besides, 2x the double the quote, They made it So I owed a lot of money, Which I knew I did not. I had to go get a 2nd Opinion.. I went to another text company which which did my taxes correctly .. I called to get a refund from mcnay, They said they would get back to me.. A week later and no response.. I. Would definitely go somewhere else, These people Care nothing for you...
• SM

  Susan Morgan

  Mar 3, 2023
  5.0
  I have used McNay and Messick for over 5 years and have been very satisfied. They are helpful and efficient, and can do both personal and business taxes. 5 stars!
• JS

  Jeff Smith

  Apr 29, 2021
  5.0
  I have been using McNay CPA for both personal and company taxes for over a decade. This 5 star review is long overdue. If you are looking for a CPA firm that cares and is price right, you won't go wrong here. They do a great job.
• JB

  Joe Burnich

  Aug 11, 2015
  5.0
  I've been working with Jim McNay for about 5 years now. They take care of my accounting and payroll for my business. What an amazing group of people. They really care about each and every client and always go above and beyond. I feel like they are a true partner. Thanks!