Lucy Blue Pizza OTR

Reviews

• MM

  Michael Morelli

  5 days ago
  5.0
  The food is excellent AND inexpensive. The meatball sub is very tasty. The raspberry vinaigrette is excellent.
• ER

  Evan Rowekamp

  Oct 10, 2025
  5.0
  Amazing place to go to finish the night. Became an end of date tradition. Great people, food, and atmosphere.
• RA

  Rini A

  Oct 10, 2025
  5.0
  Called in a large order for an event same day and everything was perfect! Great service, great food!
• JM

  Jon Monahan

  Oct 9, 2025
  5.0
  Just had the Italian sub, and was blown away. The owner was super friendly, and the staff was awesome as well. Highly recommend for a casual meal.
• JM

  JC Martinez-Sifre

  Oct 1, 2025
  5.0
  The atmosphere is stale. The dining in area is just too big. It would've really had some charm if there was no seating and only standing bannisters to gobble down a slice. Now their slice is outstanding. I'd wager it could rival any of legendary NYC pizza joint. I mean, it's the real-deal NY slice. If I thought the notion would find purchase, I'd suggest to them paint over the blue accents on the ceiling frescoes like those in Grand Central Station; and/or just some puffy clouds to retain the signature blue a la "Lucy Blue." It really is a remarkable hue of blue.