Joey's NY Pizza

Reviews

• PB

  Philip Banach

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Placed online order, had to call and push it back, staff was happy to assist, everything came out exactly as ordered and was excellent
• AJ

  Ashley Jorgensen

  5 days ago
  3.0
  Update: Joey's asked us to return and try their food again. The second time was definitely better. Our food was ready once we got there. The pizza we got this time was way better. You could actually taste the toppings. The wings were juicy and saucy. The garlic knots, were by far the best item though from this restaurant. This time they were cooked through and so delicious. Thank you Joey's staff for making this redo a lot better for us. We had a horrible experience. It was our first time trying Joey's and we most likely will never be back. We showed up after ordering online at the exact time that they said the pizza would be ready to pick up. After checking in with staff, we were told 10 minute wait (no big deal). After 45 minutes went by, I went back up to ask about our food, I was told another 5 minutes. When we got home, the pizza had ZERO flavor, the garlic knots were doughy, and the chicken wings were so dry that not enough sauce could fix them. I know others in there were frustrated too because the staff ignored them as they walked in the door. This place, mind you, was not very busy! As someone who has worked in a pizza place before, way busier than Joey's, I was extremely unhappy with the service and food.
• MG

  Meiko's a G.

  Oct 12, 2025
  2.0
  So we're not from this area and we decided to go grab lunch; we got a slice and a sub. They were short staffed that day so we decided to have some forgiveness and some compassion even though the sub sandwich took 37+ minutes to get out to us on a to go order that we waited in the restaurant for. We honest to God think that the staff forgot about our sub sandwich, and we had to keep bugging them to get it made on time. Later that night we regretted not getting a full sized pizza, so we ordered a four topping pizza. A margarita add pepperoni, (nothing overly convoluted) and got delivery over the phone. The pizza was missing half its toppings burnt on the bottom. The entire price delivery, tip, tax, and all was vehemently high !!!! We spent about $50 and that was not including the lunch that we had ordered earlier that afternoon. When we spoke to the night staff over the phone that same night they said that they would compensate us by "giving us a free pizza the next afternoon" (a pepperoni and cheese), but refused to remake the order that they had gotten wrong originally without charging us full price all over again. We wasted gas money driving back over there just so that way they could tell us that over the phone that we were getting nothing after all. The free pizza we got with our original order was just a simple cheese, but was completely burnt on the bottom also, and we couldn't even enjoy that pizza either. Both managers that we talk to were extremely rude to us, but one particularly stood out like a sore thumb and kept screaming at us through the phone: "But the pizza(s) were good, wasn't it?!?! But the food was good, wasn't it?!?!" ^^ No it wasn't any good, and eventually we had to hang up and just let it go. They refused to give us a refund on any of our order other than the four dollars for the toppings that they missed. I will not recommend this place to anyone. Even having to buy a brand new pizza with only 15% off the order is completely unacceptable after all this drama. The food was so mediocre. They were trying to blame us the customers for the fact that they were horribly understaffed. Believe me when I say anyone can advertise themselves as the best pizza place of anywhere, but this was most definitely not it !!!! Two start service.
• ML

  Mark Legg

  Oct 11, 2025
  4.0
  Joey’s is always a great go to for great tasting pizza. The location on the corner of 8th St is very convenient for a pickup. Staff are always friendly and the Pizza is always tasty. If they did Detroit style they would pickup an extra star 😉
• NT

  Nydia Cabello Teter

  Oct 9, 2025
  5.0
  Our go-to when we want no-fail, yummy pizza with the BEST crust. And you can’t go wrong with that incredible honey vinaigrette!