Business Details
About
Ice Cream ShopDessert Shop
Located in Salisbury, Maryland we churn out frozen desserts daily in small batches right in our shop. We use an all-natural premium butterfat mix from Lancaster County cows ensuring a rich, creamy ice cream. Inspiration for flavors come from the local fruit available to us or from tasty inclusions made in our kitchen. Since 1975, our family has served the Island and its neighboring communities as well as countless visitors.
Details
- Dine-inNot available
- DeliveryNot available
- TakeoutAvailable
- Credit cardAvailable
Location
Hours
Reviews
4.8
882 reviews
5 stars
780
4 stars
78
3 stars12
2 stars4
1 star8
What are people saying?
AI-generated from customer reviews
Ice Cream Quality
Customers consistently praised the ice cream for its delicious flavors, creaminess, and large portion sizes.
Service
The staff is frequently described as friendly, efficient, and helpful, contributing to a positive customer experience.
Atmosphere
The shop is noted for its pleasant atmosphere, making it a great place to enjoy ice cream with family and friends.
Location Issues
Some customers reported issues with accessibility and parking, particularly when the shop is busy.
Pricing Concerns
A few reviews mentioned that prices have increased while portion sizes have decreased, leading to dissatisfaction.
- JCJohn CollierOct 21, 20251.0Drove 20 miles after checking online to see if they were open, and they had the driveway blocked off with a car and cones lol. Worst island creamery location by far
- CCCindy ColemanOct 13, 20255.0Sooo yummy! We love making a stop here when we are in town!
- ADaapri DormanOct 4, 20255.0This is one of my favorite places to come to. Every time I come to Salisbury! It used to be TCBY but the creamery is definitely here to stay.
- SSSalisbury Secret ShopperOct 1, 20252.0The atmosphere at Island Creamery has always been a great place to visit and get a sweet treat for as long as I can remember. However, in my most recent visit, the sweet smell of waffle cones has been overpowered by the strong foul odor of marijuana from the moment I opened the door. It's hard to go many places around Salisbury now a days without being enveloped in the distinct odor of marijuana and my most recent visit was truly no different. They have established a quality product and I hope they strive to maintain a quality at this location for patrons to visit.
- CDCody DonaldsSep 30, 20255.0Always a fantastic experience. The young staff is very friendly and efficient!