Hartke Insurance

4.5
195 reviews

About

Insurance AgencyHome Insurance AgencyAuto Insurance AgencyLife Insurance AgencyRenter's Insurance AgencyBoat Insurance AgencyMotorcycle Insurance AgencyBusiness Insurance Service
Hartke Insurance was started in 1948 by C.W. Hartke of Evansville, Indiana. He went door to door, offering Fire Insurance Policies for about $12.00 per year. He would huddle around a client’s coal furnace to keep warm, talking about what could happen if those coal embers were to start a fire on the rug or a chimney fire if the furnace became too hot. A lot has changed through the years. Although we no longer go door to door, we still operate as small family owned business. We help each other and care about our customers. Our goal is to provide the best price and service we can for the coverage you choose. You will notice we say for the coverage YOU choose. We want everyone to have the best coverage, but we also realize that everyone’s budget and individual circumstances are not the same. Hartke Insurance has come to specialize in auto insurance, although we offer most other lines as well. Our theme is “Great Auto Rates” for all drivers, Ultra-Preferred, Preferred, Standard, and high risk. We hope to cut down on customer’s frustration and wasted time by doing the shopping for you. We will work hard to place your coverage through our agency as quickly and painlessly as possible. Try clicking on one of our links for your free no obligation quote. We think you’ll be glad your did.

Location

Hartke Insurance
809 S. Green River Road, Evansville, IN
47715, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.5
195 reviews
5 stars
140
4 stars
27
3 stars
15
2 stars
3
1 star
10
  • SF
    Stephanie Fowler
    Sep 24, 2025
    5.0
    I love this insurance agency friendly very helpful and very knowledgeable and they help you find the right coverage that you need thank you for all of your help
  • JT
    Jennifer Tramill
    Nov 10, 2019
    5.0
    Great deal 👍
  • NL
    Nelson LeDoux
    Nov 8, 2019
    5.0
    No frills, but awesome service and fantastic rates!
  • MK
    Marvin Kirk
    Jan 10, 2019
    4.0
    A great price the shop for insurance

Frequently Asked Questions About Hartke Insurance

Can you get insurance without a driver's license?

Yes, it is possible to obtain insurance without a driver's license. Hartke Insurance collaborates with more than 25 insurance providers, many of which offer coverage for individuals who have never been licensed, have a suspended or expired license, or possess a foreign license. For more information about our home and auto insurance options in Evansville, IN, please contact us today.

Do I have to come to the office to purchase a policy?

No, visiting our office is not necessary to purchase a policy. We offer multiple convenient options, including email, phone, or mail transactions. This flexibility is one of the reasons why Hartke Insurance is a highly recommended independent insurance agency in Evansville, IN.