Grandmas NY Pizza

Reviews

• GP

  Grip p

  today
  1.0
  New York pizza only by name... it's like calling yourself a New Yorker because you wear a Yankees cap. This place is a joke/trash. Go to little ceasars pizza at least its fresh, service is better and at least you get what you pay for. The service and the food is an example of a good thing gone wrong... it's having the wrong people running the business. It's clear dude working probably makes some bad ass tacos but pizza is definitely not their strength. They have several locations, I use to take my family to Suwanee location long time ago when owners were onsite. Once they opened Cumming location, I WAS excited when both brothers were there. There had a great selection of pizzas you could order by the slice, some nice pinwheels, slices looked like they were made this that day. If you wanted to order something custom they charged you for it but at least it was awesome. I walked in today the Grandmas "pizza" was about 1/4" thick PAPERTHIN dryed left over & the slices of pizza Don't even get me started... I have seen better leftover Tombstone frozen pizza found 4 days later in a dorm!! I asked for pinwheels or fresh slice and it was like I was asking for his first born and let's not play the I don't understand english so well card. To the brother i recall owning this location Go Clean House your boy cooking isnt cutting it... How are they still in business???
• DP

  Dillon Pinkerton

  2 days ago
  1.0
  Every employee was on a phone call. Spent $50 for a 14" pizza, a Caesar Salad, and 2 waters. Food was quick, pizza was terrible. Sweet tomato sauce, no cheese, under cooked toppings, and a greasy mess. Good thing was they had every seasoning available to make it taste somewhat descent.
• KK

  Keith

  Oct 4, 2025
  5.0
  Best pizza and wings around. We’ve tried all the alternatives, none come close.
• RG

  Rob G

  Sep 16, 2025
  5.0
  The authenticity is amazing. Delicious pizza. You can’t stop eating it 🤣.
• AC

  Adam C

  Sep 11, 2025
  5.0
  Delicious! Creative pizza creations that might seem odd but give it a try, you will be back for more! We can't get enough of this place