Goodfellas Pizza & Wings

Reviews

• JL

  Jennifer Leach

  Oct 14, 2025
  5.0
  This is my go to for quick, fast and good. The food is always hot, pick-up or delivery. The rewards program is saver too.
• CS

  Charlene Strayhon

  Oct 13, 2025
  3.0
  I want to be clear the Goodfellas pizza that used to deliver to our area evem though they were in Marietta or on Marietta St in Atlanta was MUCH better. I miss them but they stopped delivering due to distance. I was hungry last night so I gave this other location a 3rd chance. I am a CHEF. I know that to make tasty, non slick eggplant you need to salt it let it sit, drain and pat off any moisture, season and then bread with bread crumbs to have a proper eggplant for parmigiana. There's has no breading , is very slick and not tasty at all. The pasta itself is overrun with too much cheese as if to hide the shortcomings of the eggplant. Please take the time to prepare the eggplant properly. The other location also provides a much larger serving size.
• CM

  Calvin McCaslin

  Oct 11, 2025
  2.0
  Not the best pizza in the world. The sauce is sweet like barbecue sauce on the triple cheese-- it just wasn't good, and the pizza itself smelled like McDonald's.
• JG

  John Givens

  Oct 6, 2025
  1.0
  Worst pizza I’ve ever ordered. Hands down. Little Caesar’s would have been better than this. I don’t even think I could get a homeless person to take a slice of this. Terrible staff & atmosphere and I would not be returning to this location. I’ve always enjoyed GoodFellas, but this experience has even caused me to fear returning to any location. I think I might take my chances with places like Night Owl, so I know it won’t turn out like this sorry excuse of a pizza.
• PC

  Paul “PC” Cannella

  Sep 27, 2025
  2.0
  For the 3rd time in a row, my order wasn’t ready when I arrived. They tell me 5 minutes, but obviously just start making my order when I arrive. Sat there for over 30 minutes while every other customer picked up there order within a couple minutes. Decent food n price, close to my house, but their attitude to resolving the problem, and incompetence is ridiculous. I deleted the app and won’t be back.