Glass Nickel Pizza Co. Sun Prairie

Reviews

• HP

  Harish Patel

  Oct 8, 2025
  5.0
  Enjoyed pizza, loved it
• TH

  Tanya Hanson

  Oct 3, 2025
  1.0
  I will never order from the sun prairie glass nickel again! Not only was my 30 Pizza terrible beyond belief but the aftermath was horrifying!!! I called the next day to tell them about my experience and how my pizza turned out and that I ended up throwing it away after one piece. I spoke with the GM Kimmy who seemed frustrated and stated she would call me back in an hour. She did not. Later that evening I called back and was hung up on twice. I was very polite however I’m assuming they have caller ID and didn’t want to deal with it. The next day I called twice and was put on hold for 45 minutes as kimmy was busy the first time and the second time she was not available. I left my information with the person that answered the phone to please have her call me but she never did. The next day going on day three I called and asked to speak with her again and they stated she was not there. Then I asked to speak with Adam the owner and was told he was busy. I then stated I would just go in there and all of a sudden he gets on the phone. Frustrated knowing the situation he said.. what is it you want me to do for you!! This is the owner asking me what he can do for me after I had explained all this! This was beyond frustrating. Very poor poor attitudes and ways of handling things! I would never treat someone this way in a business.
• LW

  Lee Wallander

  Sep 27, 2025
  5.0
  I did not know this place had a bar too. Decent place to watch a game. Pizza is good. Will be back.
• SJ

  Sam Johnson

  Sep 23, 2025
  5.0
  🍕😀
• YO

  Young One

  Aug 30, 2025
  3.0
  Good service & I'm sure the food is great but it's way too overpriced. $15 for a small 10 inch pizza, $12 Mac & Cheese, $20 16" cheese bread, $16 salads, $10 tiny subs. Like I said I'm sure the food is great but it's way too expensive for the average person. Nice environment & service though,