First Group Insurance

4.5
20 reviews
First Group Insurance Agency is your locally owned and operated insurance agency for over 80 years.

About

Insurance AgencyAuto Insurance AgencyBusiness Insurance ServiceHome Insurance AgencyLife Insurance AgencyMotorcycle Insurance AgencyProperty Insurance AgencyRenter's Insurance Agency
First Group Insurance Agency provides home, auto, life, farm, and trucking for hire insurance to customers in Troy, New Carlisle, OH, as well as all of Miami, Clark, Champaign, Shelby and Montgomery counties in Ohio.

Details

  • Wheelchair accessible entranceAvailable
  • Wheelchair accessible restroomAvailable
  • Wheelchair accessible seatingAvailable

Location

First Group Insurance
309 N Main Street, New Carlisle, OH
45344, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.5
20 reviews
5 stars
17
4 stars
0
3 stars
0
2 stars
2
1 star
1
  • TP
    Tom Perry
    Jul 29, 2025
    5.0
    Greg and his staff are excellent to work with. They always respond in a timely manner to any questions or concerns we have. With their experience and expertise, you can feel confident that should anything happen, they will do their best to help you. I highly recommend giving Greg and his team call for all your insurance needs.
  • MM
    Money Moves
    Aug 5, 2019
    5.0
    I have been w First Group for over 25 yrs for my insurance needs. Recently I had an issue, but Alisha did her due deligence and put forth tireless efforts to make sure the issue was evaluated in great detail. She followed through to rectify the situation promptly and with genuine concern. Thank you Alisha for a job well done!
  • AL
    Alyssa Lane
    Jul 2, 2018
    5.0
    Couldn’t find a better company to go through! They were awesome at finding me the best rate for my home owners insurance and most of all they were very personable! That’s hard to come by and so much appreciated finding a good rate insurance is stressful enough but they made it all so easy!