Since 1987, First Choice Insurance Agency, Inc. has been providing clients in the NYC area with world-class insurance service and products. Our clients are so satisfied with our service that over 70% of our new clients are referred to us by them!
Affordable Auto Insurance, Affordable Business Insurance, Affordable Car Insurance, Auto Insurance, Builders Risk Insurance, Business Insurance, Car Insurance, Cheap Auto Insurance, Cheap Business Insurance, Cheapest Car Insurance, Commercial Insurance, Contractors Insurance, Flood Insurance, General Liability Insurance, Health Insurance, Home Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Insurance, Medical Insurance, Small Business Insurance, Tool and Equipment Insurance, CGL Insurance
Amazing place, has always gotten me the best price even when everything seems so expensive and bleak. They work with you, understand and do their best. Amazing people and an Incredible company for the people
EV
E VanAlphen
Jun 25, 2025
5.0
This place is great. Jadery and Kelly took care of all my needs. I would recommend this agency to everyone I know. Believe me it's definitely worth checking into for all your insurance needs and the price is right. 10 stars is more appropriate.
MI
Maria Iacono
Jun 13, 2025
5.0
Carmella is a knowledgeable agent & a sweet person she makes you feel right at home. It’s a pleasure being her customer.
AT
Anthony Tringone
Jan 9, 2024
5.0
Fantastic and patient lady's there. God bless them ,❤️
ND
N Duncan
Feb 26, 2019
5.0
I had the most amazing experience with Melissa. She was very nice and got me a great rate in just a few minutes. Best Agent I spoke with and I called several companies! I will recommend her to anyone looking for car insurance!