Farmerstown Meats

4.8
26 reviews

About

Butcher Shop
A staple in Amish Country since 1972, Farmerstown Meats has more than a half-century expertise in meat processing. Our butcher is well versed in all cuts of beef and pork, as well as lamb, goat and wild game (deer, elk, moose, bear). As a custom butcher shop, we receive the animal carcass from the slaughterhouse and develop a cut list, then slice and package the meat to customer’s specifications. We are a cut above in everything we do: from aging all of our beef to smoking meats only using all-natural hickory chips to flavoring our smokies and jerky with non-MSG spices. We let the beef age for 12 to 16 days to let the muscle enzymes break down. This extra step makes the meat more tender. We also smoke meats for customers in our butcher shop. Using all-natural hickory chips, we can smoke anything, including turkey, ham and bacon. Plus, we make smokies and jerkies with seven different flavors ranging from Honey to Hawaiian Barbecue. We also offer deer processing for those who hunt and want to drop off the deer so we can skin, debone and process the meat all in-house. And we take special care to make sure you get own meat back. We are proud to be part of the community for so many decades and look forward to more product offerings this year.

Details

  • DeliveryNot available
  • Requires appointmentAvailable
  • Credit cardAvailable
  • DebitNot available

Location

Farmerstown Meats
2934 TOWNSHIP ROAD 163, Sugarcreek, OH
44681, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.8
26 reviews
5 stars
25
4 stars
0
3 stars
0
2 stars
0
1 star
1
  • BS
    brandon saylor
    Oct 16, 2025
    1.0
    I have to begin with everyone was very kind but… I dropped off 75lbs of venison for hotdogs and trail bologna and when I got back today I was excited to try it and it was quite honestly terrible. It looks nice but both hot dogs and bologna were off tasting. Not sure what to do. Do I throw all of $171 worth of meat away?
  • MR
    Michelle Roth
    Aug 16, 2025
    5.0
    We’re always very pleased with our cuts from Farmerstown Meats! We’ve been raising our own hogs for a few years now, and had them butchered locally. We tried FM after a friend had a great experience there. It was a bit of a drive, but we wanted to try something different. We’ve been using FM for the last 3 years now, and they never disappoint!! They are always available to answer my questions, and have been super flexible with scheduling changes! We appreciate their professionalism, and friendliness! Thank you, Jonas, for doing such a top job at making the most of my freezer hogs!
  • JK
    Jessica Kuhn
    May 8, 2025
    5.0
    Excellent service and best prices we have found.lots of choices to fit any budget.will buy again.Thank you
  • CW
    Chad Waibel
    Mar 6, 2024
    5.0
    Great People delivering great service!! All my meats have been cut and packaged to perfection!!! Thank you Farmerstown Meats!!!
  • DP
    Dana Pettit
    Feb 1, 2024
    5.0
    Excellent customer service, great pricing, and the best meat cutters in the area! Jonas and Katie are awesome to deal with!! Highly recommend!!!!