El Pollito Pio Ice Cream Shop + More

Reviews

• AG

  Airanna “AqariOneNess” Godwin

  5 days ago
  5.0
  I love the customer service, el pollito pio was informational to food choices. And Tacos was amazing. Thank you.
• SS

  S S

  Nov 1, 2025
  5.0
  Excellent, authentic Mexican food and unique drinks. I travel a lot and I'm always on the look out for new, interesting food. I could tell from the menu that this place was going to be great. They have items that I've never seen before, so I had to try a bunch. For dinner, I ate the quesa birria tacos which were so juicy and just as good as the so called best birria tacos in NYC. Birria tacos are the hot new trend, and they are delicious. For drinks, I tried the hibiscus aqua fresca and tamarind aqua loca. I love hibiscus drinks, so of course, I'd love it, but the aqua loca was even more interesting. Omar made it for me, and it's his own recipe he came up with. He even makes a version with monster energy drinks that is really unique. For dessert, I tried the egg nog and churrochito ice creams. Both were excellent and so rich and milky. There's so much more items I could try, but I'm stuffed and just passing through. Sun Prairie is lucky to have such a great Mexican restaurant.
• DB

  Dulce Barrera

  Oct 22, 2025
  5.0
  The place is a nice place to go for a yummy snack, service is excellent and very welcoming. The worker Nelly’s service is top notch, and very friendly!! Would recommend. Ice cream is yummy too
• DD

  David Duncan

  Oct 22, 2025
  5.0
  Thanks Nelly for always smiling and making sure my food is prepared properly! Glad yall out here in Sun Prairie taking care of the community! Great food excellent customer service!
• GV

  Gerber Vang

  Oct 18, 2025
  5.0
  This is my second time here. Our server Nelly was awesome. Food was also delicious. I love eating Mexican food and they did not disappoint