Earl and Isabella's Taverna

Reviews

• TW

  Terri Wilson

  4 days ago
  5.0
  First time visit. Tried pepperoni and barbecue chicken pizzas. Crust was fantastic on both. Pepperoni pizza was great. BBQ chicken was good, but light in sauce and chicken was a little bland. Overall though, very good experience. Server Jonathan was very nice, attentive and funny!
• CH

  Carly Harrison

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Love this place! It has become our go to pizza place for both in person and take home. We love to bring friends and family here when they are in town. Food is delicious and staff are phenomenal. Best of all it is dog friendly!
• MA

  Madelyn Abeyta

  5 days ago
  5.0
  We had a great experience! We ordered pasta and pizza to share. The corn ravioli was a little too weird and out there but it still tasted good. Uncle Carmen’s pizza was fabulous! Awesome flavors and a crust that’s both crispy and soft. The vibe is amazing and unique. The keyboardist is a nice touch and we loved the overall atmosphere. Service was also wonderful. Jonathan was our server and he was charming and funny as well as helpful and kind. I can’t wait to come back!
• AA

  Andrew

  Oct 10, 2025
  5.0
  Went for the new pasta dishes and they were delicious! The spaghetti, while it sounds boring, was PERFECTLY al dente and delicious! Tasting the pasta took me right back to Italy! The flavors were FULL! The pictures don’t do it justice, but this food is worth eating!!
• DH

  David Hume (David H)

  Sep 25, 2025
  4.0
  Earl & Isabella's Taverna, formerly Earl's on 377, is a very unique restaurant with plenty of character, following the current trend of converted industrial buildings. This having been a Fire Station I believe. Well Done. The menu, aside from Pizza, is very limited, however the spaghetti & meatballs, has a more Italian name on the menu, is spectacular and very flavorful with generous portions. We would frequent this hidden gem more often if it had more menu selections of this caliber. The servers, mostly very young, are inexperienced but helpful & enthusiastic. Our server this last visit was young, but Extraordinary in his skills, thus double the standard tip. You absolutely must try this place if you live nearby. Being in Argyle, there are always interesting vehicles in the parking lot, like this McClaren Hyper-Car Hybrid last time we visited