Donatos Pizza - closed

Reviews

• RT

  Robert Torrado

  Aug 25, 2024
  1.0
  Super disappointed with the bait and switch this is what they advertise and this is what you get. How are they going to describe a large pepperoni pizza with pepperonis from crust to crust and then you get this monstrosity delivered to you? Super heavy on sauce absolutely nothing for pepperoni on a pizza that was way over $20 and literally have had better tasting pizza from Walmart frozen food section. Never again!!! My complaint is on the amount of or lack there of pepperonis on this pizza. You can clearly count almost no pepperonis on it but the picture on the other pizzas Literally have 4 to 5 times the amount of pepperonis. So the owner writes that the thin crust and the deep dish version of the large have over 100 pepperonis meanwhile, if you order the hand toss you get about 20 Pepperoni that’s funny because it doesn’t say that stuff when you order it and then oh it’s a trading issue we can address. Well, it definitely needs to be addressed especially if they’re throwing 100 pepperonis on a pizza for the picture and 20 on the actual pizza when you get it deep dish or crust the amount of pepperoni shouldn’t change.
• SS

  SANEL SANEL

  Jun 2, 2023
  4.0
  Good pizza, just had a little too much tomato sauce.
• MB

  Monika Benesh

  Oct 8, 2022
  4.0
  First pizza place outside of Buffalo (moved here recently for college) and honestly, pretty mixed experience. Visited: 10/07/22. Ordered: Medium sausage, pepperoni, and mushroom pizza. Firstly, the employees when I visited were super nice and they got our pizza and wings out quickly. Since we ordered the pizza half no mushrooms, plus the wings half BBQ and half parmesan, they even offered to split the boxes for us! Secondly, the pizza. The pizza was surprisingly good, nice and crispy and not too greasy. No complaints here. The wings though. . . Egh. The BBQ was great but the meat was. . . Questionable. It was mainly squishy, I had to basically dissect my wings to get actual meat. Overall though, other than the wings, pretty solid!
• MT

  Mark T

  Jul 23, 2021
  5.0
  My hats off to Ryan and Kevin at the east 38st location. My apartment building decided that they wanted to have a pizza party yesterday and I suggested that they get pizza from Donatos. Most here at my apartment complex had never had anything from Donatos before but decided to go ahead and order from Donatos at my suggestion. I must admit as always Donatos came through with flying colors. The food was excellent the salad was excellent and everyone here was very pleased. Again Ryan and Kevin thank you for a pleasurable experience!! You guys made it all happen!! I know for a fact that you will have several more customers from our apartment building after yesterday’s experience!! Keep up the great work!!