Cottage Inn Pizza

Reviews

• JH

  Jason Hanson

  Oct 3, 2025
  1.0
  I ordered a large Greek salad and there was like four olives on there two tomatoes, two banana peppers, three little slivers of onion, 5 small beets on there. I don’t know if I’ll be coming back for $15 large salad. I should’ve just got the small salad. There was barely anything on it. There was no toppings on it. That’s not how we made the food when I worked there back in 1998. I used to work at the old Grove Road store. If I remember this store is owned by Shafi and his son Nick. I’ve worked in Pizza industry here in Ann Arbor for at least 20+ years and I know that vegetables is not an expensive food cost item like cheese or meat. The guy that was taking my order seems really lost not trained. It took him forever to take my order on the computer. I asked him to swap out the Greek dressing for Italian dressing and added Italian dressing as an extra charge and I told him I want to swap it out that should be free, but he was gonna charge me extra to swap it out.. I won’t be coming back here. Once I open the bag and saw how they had made my salad I asked another driver or somebody working in the back to make the salad correctly. Even he seemed completely lost as how to make anything there. was no one in the store.. I wonder why maybe because the food just sucks and it’s overpriced. I wouldn’t complain if it was like a $9.99 salad but I paid like $15. I wanted to try the cream cheese garlic dip with breadsticks, but it comes with marinara and I didn’t want marinara because it’s gonna give me acid reflux. The person taking my order couldn’t understand how to swap it out. He just wanted to charge me extra so I told him just forget it. forget the breadsticks, forget the sauce and the cream cheese garlic dip. I’ll just get my salad. Just an awful experience.
• DL

  david leedy

  Aug 25, 2025
  4.0
  The Pizza was okay but a little high-priced. If you asked me
• RH

  R. Hibbard

  Aug 12, 2025
  1.0
  I ordered sesame seed crust. When I got home I noticed the crust of the pizza was salty as hell, it turns out the gave me everything crust even though the box says sesame seed. I have high blood pressure and can now only eat the middle of the pizza because the salt is even mixed in to the edge of the cheese. Even without health concerns there is just way too much salt to even be able to eat this. They offered to remake it, but I picked it up on my way home and am miles away. They also offered a partial credit, but they ruined the pizza, so a partial credit isn't enough. So I will not be returning to this location. The turnover of employees is unbelievable, and that apparently means they don't know how to do their jobs.
• SA

  Santino Amourii

  Jul 28, 2025
  5.0
  Nice and cool on the inside and the lady at the register was nice, Cottage Inn is one of the better places to get pizza and other items food wise
• NN

  Nessa

  Jul 22, 2025
  1.0
  This location needs to retrain its workers. I watched them overcharge a customer, and when the customer calmly asked why they were overcharged, the employee tried to gaslight the customer and threatened to call the police!! I have never seen anything so absurd in my life! 7/22/25 7:00 pm I AM REQUESTING ANY HIGHER UPS TO PLAY THE CAMERA FOOTAGE BACK AND HAVE A TALK WITH THAT EMPLOYEE.

Frequently Asked Questions About Cottage Inn Pizza