City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar

Reviews

• PR

  Pico Rod

  Oct 13, 2025
  2.0
  We visited this place as it had good reviews. For starters we began with chips and salsa and fried pickles - the salsa that came out was very watery and nothing stuck to the chip. The fried pickles were very salty. We were told by our waitress that the pickles were salty that's why the fried pickles tasted salty. Our meals included buffalo chicken sandwich and fries. That was okay nothing that stood out. Catfish meal - onion rings were salty not much flavor, catfish was okay. Baked potato came out warm not hot, so nothing melted when it came out. Taste was okay. The sweet tea we ordered you could taste the strong taste of the tea possibly temperature or steeping for too long. Our service was also okay - there were maybe 5 tables at best and we waited over 30 minutes for our food. Waitress could have been more tentative to our table. I was very disappointed that out of all the meals and appetizers nothing stood out or tasted delicious medium food at best.
• ST

  Sim Traw

  Oct 11, 2025
  3.0
  Dinner with 5 friends at 7pm total of 12 people in restaurant. Slow service the whole night! Food was not hot when it finally arrived aprox. 40 min from time it was ordered to put on table . Food was not all served at once people were left sitting while others were eating ! Place was freezing! Asked to turn air down and was told only the owner could do that ? Manager came out and apologized for slow service and explained they had a lot of take out orders ! She did offer a discount of 10 percent and free pie .! I would have much more enjoyed my meal.if 1 the place was a decent temperature. The food and service was faster ! They should know that a friday and Saturday night would be be busier since they offer pick ups ! And why is the pick up order more important then the people that visit the establishment? Not my first choice for a revisit !
• MG

  Maddy Gutierrez

  Oct 7, 2025
  3.0
  3 guests. We ordered 3 meals. 2 of the meals were the same. One item on each of the 2 meals had a side that smelled and tasted odd. We told the server and the server who was extremely delightful, did not credit the sides to our bill because they were meals. Not sure what that meant. He did say that he told the cook but they didn't do anything about it. I did ask him if he credited those 2 sides and he said no because it was part of the meals. But he saw that it was not eaten on either dish. Also, he didn't go check with the manager to see if it would get credited. He just said it was part of the meal. We just left it at that. Paid the bill and left. He did get a tip because he was a good server and very joyful, but he should've gotten the manager involved in something that smells and tastes odd. I doubt if I'll be back there but the other 2 people that were with me might go back. I don't know, but I won't be back. But the rest of the items were fine and the server was very kind.
• MM

  Monica Marks

  Oct 5, 2025
  3.0
  I have bought coconut cream pies from here on several occasions and they were excellent! I bought one on 10/02/25 and we cut it today 10/05/25 for my Mom’s birthday and the crust was flaky but tastes burnt! The presentation and the filling of the pie were wonderful as always but the aftertaste of burnt crust ruined it! I was disappointed to say the least! While the crust wasn’t black, it was dark brown color and crumbly as and burnt tasting!
• JP

  Juanita Penoyer

  Sep 29, 2025
  1.0
  Went this past Saturday with my kids and $107 later we left very disappointed. Our server was okay just seem annoyed the whole time and got our drinks wrong and my son’s food order . Now let’s talk about how the food took forever and maybe over price and not good ! The glaze pork chops was thin and dry . My son wanted chicken fried steak and he got chicken fried steak in strips and the mashed potatoes NO SEASONING. They steak for $23 dollars had no season and they won’t bring you a steak knife ( we asked for one ) The Mac and cheese tasted old. My 10 year old didn’t eat it ! I was gonna say something but we had to leave due to the food taking forever we were late to our other plans !

Frequently Asked Questions About City Hall Cafe & Pie Bar