Buena Vista Restaurant Mar Y Tierra

4.4
207 reviews

About

Mexican Restaurant

Location

Buena Vista Restaurant Mar Y Tierra
220 N Harrison St, Algonquin, IL
60102, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.4
207 reviews
5 stars
155
4 stars
24
3 stars
6
2 stars
4
1 star
18

What are people saying?

AI-generated from customer reviews

Food Quality

Customers frequently praised the food as delicious, authentic, and well-prepared, with standout items like steak and al pastor tacos.

Service

The staff received numerous compliments for being friendly, attentive, and accommodating, contributing to a welcoming atmosphere.

Ambiance

The restaurant's location by the river and its cozy interior were highlighted positively, enhancing the dining experience.

Pricing

While many found the prices reasonable, some customers expressed concerns about high prices relative to food quality.

Inconsistency

A few reviews noted issues with food quality and service consistency, indicating that experiences can vary.
  • JJ
    josh Edwards (Josh)
    2 days ago
    5.0
    Best Mexican around hands down. Meals are huge!
  • JH
    Joanna Herula
    Oct 25, 2025
    5.0
    We just tried this place for the first time! Wish we tried it sooner, being in Algonquin down the road for five years. I went in and ordered to go, should have called achead cuz it was busy! That’s my fault though! Took a little bit. I had steak, pork and shrimp tacos and ceviche torta! The tacos were amazing! Steak on the tacos was probably the best steak we have had around town! Will be going there from now on! Cute place inside too! The chef and server were very nice and can tell they care a lot about their customers!
  • TA
    Tina Alford
    Oct 17, 2025
    5.0
    The restaurant brought back memories...the food was good, price was reasonable..quick and friendly especially for a larger order
  • PP
    Phillip Petersen
    Oct 12, 2025
    5.0
    I ordered a bunch of taco meat/fixins for my daughter's birthday and I got tons of compliments. Everything was as delicious as it is when sitting down and eating in the restaurant. Will definitely be ordering from them for large events in the future. The barbacoa, steak, and pork are my personal favorites, and it was so nice to have leftovers.
  • TP
    Teresa Parayil
    Oct 5, 2025
    5.0
    Such a hidden gem in Algonquin! The Al Pastor tacos were incredible — so flavorful and perfectly cooked. The chips and homemade salsas and sauces were some of the best I’ve had, especially the smoky chipotle one. I also loved the mango margarita — fresh and light and perfect with the tajin rim. The owners were so kind and welcoming, and great food all around. Can’t wait to come back!