Big City Bagels & Nathan's Famous Hot Dogs

Reviews

• CM

  Concetta McLean

  3 days ago
  1.0
  EDIT** I ended up messaging the business on Facebook, I tried to see if they would at least rectify the situation, but instead they just angry reacted to my actual experience. Now this place is a joke. I have to say this last time I went to Big City Bagels was an awful experience. I had a coupon, the woman at the register honestly couldn't comprehend the coupon at all and had a horrendous attitude anytime I pointed out what she said was wrong, but that's besides the point. I ordered 3 sandwiches, why was I upcharged for the bread?! Your sodas are completely flat and stale. The atmosphere was extremely cold, and the wait time was long when they weren't busy. I paid $40 for mediocre food, a cold atmosphere, and a 30+ minute wait time. I do not recommend this place.
• MF

  Melanny Fernandez

  Oct 1, 2025
  5.0
  The best bagel place in Jersey. Bagels are delicious and fluffy and the variety of cream cheeses are also really good. The staff is a pleasure to interact with. Just overall such a great bagel spot!
• KB

  Kathryn Bower

  Sep 22, 2025
  5.0
  Whatever we order it’s always great. We especially love their bagels! Best around!!
• MS

  M S

  Sep 8, 2025
  1.0
  Terrible service. 2 bagels with cream cheese should take 40 minutes. Two door dashers waited for my order and both left because they were not ready. Finally after calling the order was picked up. Now we’re over an hour and the food still is not here. Find somewhere else.
• MF

  Michele Ferraioli

  Sep 1, 2025
  5.0
  As always the staff is pleasant and professional. The place is always clean