Bartolino's The Hill

Reviews

• CL

  Constantijn Lissone

  Sep 27, 2025
  5.0
  Food was fantastic. Very large portions. Staff was great and the owner went out of his way to ensure that all guests were enjoying themselves. Definitely will be coming back.
• TT

  Tish6795

  Sep 22, 2025
  5.0
  We chose to have our happy hour drinks here & we chose to have dinner here, too. Service was excellent (bartender deserves a raise, she was great!). We split a steak & sides which were delicious. The last night we dined there I had the scallops and risotto and it was amazing! We loved dining here!
• TC

  Trent Condellone

  Sep 22, 2025
  1.0
  Disappointing. When I go out of town, I want to have something that's unique that I cannot get at home. The hotel I was staying at is attached to this restaurant. It sounded good. And they deliver to the room. Either this or White Castle I figured it'd be unique. I wish I had gotten the White Castle. I got the baked pasta combo. A large portion. A lot of meat. Fairly tasty, although I would not call it anything extremely special. However, there was practically no tomato sauce. No bread. No fork. I think it would have been better if I had more tomato sauce, well any tomato sauce LOL. The side salad was excellent, albeit expensive. No fork though. Not worth the money. Fazoli's or Olive Garden is better than this.
• TA

  Tiffany A

  Sep 22, 2025
  3.0
  I went to a party there In spring of 2024. The room was nice, the waiter was nice and efficient, the food was amazing. We had 1 waiter for over 30 people So when looking for a spot that could take a large party and accommodate separate checks, they came to mind first. The day of the party the atmosphere was nice. The food was delicious. We had several who did not rsvp to show up and the staff was very accommodating. The food was good but the wait staff was over worked 2 people serving 2 large private parties. Mine was 50 and someone mentioned that the other party was 100. Many of the guest grew tired because the wait staff was unorganized. They would bring food and just hand it to whoever. Several people refused meals because it took them too long to get them. People ordered drinks and never received them. Some of my guest grew restless and rude. At the end of the night they handed me an $800 bill with item we knew had been refused and drinks. They couldn’t tell us who had ordered what. Every was seat 1. They took something’s off but I still had a $400 bill. This is a great restaurant with great food but they need more wait staff for larger parties and the waiters didn’t seem to take order is any particular order.
• KG

  Karen G

  Sep 19, 2025
  1.0
  I placed an order and my food was all mushed up not worth the price. Overall the food was dry with very hardly any sauce. It was so expensive and the value was not there. I ordered lasagna, eggplant parm, stuffed mushrooms, an and a house salad. The bread was stale. They sent no utensils, no plates, and no napkins. The lasagna had what appeared to have only two layers of pasta but it was all mushed up and had little sauce. Overall this meal was disappointing for such a nice restaurant.