Andy Ottney - State Farm Insurance Agent

4.7
138 reviews

About

Insurance AgencyAuto Insurance AgencyHome Insurance AgencyLife Insurance AgencyRenter's Insurance AgencyMotorcycle Insurance AgencyProperty Insurance AgencyBoat Insurance AgencyBusiness Insurance Service
OH-776179 Our State Farm mission is to help people manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected, and realize their dreams. We are people who make it our business to be like a good neighbor. Our success is built on a foundation of shared principles - quality service, relationships, integrity, and financial strength. Customers' needs determine our path. Our principles guide us. Our office is here to help the Galloway community with auto, renters, homeowners, life, and business insurance.

Location

Andy Ottney - State Farm Insurance Agent
5618 Hall Rd, Galloway, OH
43119, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.7
138 reviews
5 stars
125
4 stars
3
3 stars
1
2 stars
1
1 star
8
  • JC
    Jen Carlson
    Oct 9, 2025
    5.0
    Cassidy at State Farm with Andy Ottney‘s office, hands-down you will not go wrong with this agency. They are knowledgeable, will look for the best rates, are patient, answer all questions and make sure that the customer comes first. If you’re looking for insurance, auto, home, life, disability, reach out to this group. You will not be disappointed! I take Google reviews seriously and I read reviews people write, I mean this wholeheartedly please consider this agency when looking for great people, great Insurance at great prices!!!
  • ES
    Emilee Slaughter
    Sep 16, 2025
    1.0
    Horrendous agency. I had to open a water damage claim on my home back in March and have been displaced ever since. Throughout the entire claim process, I never once heard from Andy or anyone in his office. Then in July, State Farm dropped my coverage because of the claim. Andy’s office never called, texted, or emailed me about this. Instead, they mailed the cancellation notice to my vacant address, which, of course, I didn’t receive in time. My coverage lapsed as a result. I've been with State Farm for over a year and I never received a single call from Andy or his staff until after my coverage was terminated. Andy called me ONCE, asking if I was “okay"...Very obviously, I was not. Because of their negligence, I’ve been forced to settle for subpar coverage on both my home and auto. To make matters worse, I recently received notice from another State Farm agent (Rhea Barbee @ Vic Jimenez, HIGHLY recommend her) that my auto insurance was about to cancel...I was stunned. Wasn’t my auto policy dropped back in July? Apparently not. Yet again, Andy’s office failed to provide even the most basic communication or clarification. I’ve been a loyal State Farm policyholder for years and was repeatedly told Andy Ottney was “the best.” I’ve seen no evidence to support that claim. On the contrary, his agency has caused real, lasting damage to my personal life. Now I’m stuck with inadequate coverage and living with the consequences of his office’s indifference. I would not recommend Andy Ottney or his agency to anyone. Their failure to communicate, act responsibly, or show the slightest concern for their clients is beyond unacceptable. The damage is done, and his office remains just as absent today as it was when I first opened my policy.
  • CW
    Cody Worrix
    Aug 20, 2025
    5.0
    Excellent service and incredibly informative. I could not recommend them enough.
  • SF
    Samantha Ferguson
    Aug 15, 2025
    5.0
    Garrett and Cassidy are the dream team
  • RG
    Ronald Gorenflo
    Jul 18, 2025
    5.0
    I appreciate these guys. I've been with State farm for my adult life and I'm not young. I needed a policy on a 2nd home and got what I needed in a couple hours on a Friday afternoon! Good agent, good staff!

Frequently Asked Questions About Andy Ottney - State Farm Insurance Agent

Do I have to pay for a quote online?

No, you do not have to pay for a quote online. We offer free quotes!

Who do I contact if I have questions about billing or payments?

Please contact your agent if you have questions about your bills, payments or Renewal Coverage Offers. Your agent's phone number and email are available on the details page of your bill.