American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream

Reviews

• JT

  Jen Thompson

  Oct 7, 2025
  5.0
  We got the Margherita pizza and fries. Everything was so good. My husband doesn’t eat the crust usually but he couldn’t get enough of it. He said it was like eating garlic bread. We will definitely be back.
• MG

  Mike Gund

  Oct 3, 2025
  5.0
  This is how pizza and homemade ice should be! Awesome pizza, fantastic ice cream! Warm , personable service with a smile! Pet friendly pavilion and a pup cup for my buddy! Loved it!
• TD

  Tammy Donnelly

  Oct 2, 2025
  5.0
  I stop here at least 3-4 times during a week long stay. I will actually book a room at the Motor Lodge across the street just to be near American Pie and Millers! Love the banana pudding ice cream
• AH

  Arlene Huebner

  Sep 26, 2025
  2.0
  Pizza was greasy and crust was very soggy. The place to sit in you cannt just slide in since the leg of table was to the outside so you had to lift your leg over the seat. Terrible.!
• JM

  Josh McNurlen

  Sep 26, 2025
  3.0
  We ended up sitting outside because it was so busy, and honestly, I’m glad we did. Inside felt hot and cramped, but outside was much more comfortable. The buffet itself was excellent—tons of seafood and everything we tried was delicious! That said, the place wasn’t the cleanest. The bathroom was in such bad shape it was basically unusable, which really took away from the overall experience. I get that it’s hard to keep up with that many people coming through, but if cleanliness can’t be maintained, they should consider limiting how many guests they allow in at a time. So while the food was truly amazing, the overcrowded and less-than-clean environment made it tough to give this place the rating it could have earned.

Frequently Asked Questions About American Pie Pizza & Homemade Ice Cream