American Coin And Jewelry Gallery

Reviews

• KM

  Kevin Melling

  Jul 17, 2025
  5.0
  Great experience & good people with a great price .
• SB

  Shelley Bosticco

  Jun 16, 2025
  5.0
  I highly recommend Mike at American Coin & Jewelry. After my father’s passing, I needed a valuation for his silver/coin collection, and Mike was recommended to me as a trustworthy and honest appraiser. He was quick to respond to my needs and accommodated my schedule, and he was very knowledgeable about the many different items in my father’s silver collection. During my visit, he was kind to answer any and all of my questions, and I was pleased when I walked out that day with a detailed appraisal for my father’s estate. Several months later, I called Mike in order to liquidate my father’s silver, and he once again accommodated my schedule and was quickly able to meet with me to sell the collection. In every occasion that I interacted with Mike, I was pleased with his knowledge, fairness, and honesty, and I would definitely use his services again!
• JA

  Jessica Agee

  Jun 6, 2025
  5.0
  Lovely little shop. Friendly staff with a very home feeling environment. Easy to talk to and comfortable. They were super fast sorting the coins I brought in.
• LO

  Levi O'Rourke

  Jun 6, 2025
  5.0
  I called in yesterday with a Hamilton watch and a Bulova watch. Spoke with Mike I told him the low base number that I was expecting being a realist. I’m not someone trying to squeeze a fortune out of something for somebody that has to then later sell it to retail. He was nice enough to let me know and not be a dirty, greedy businessman. He had integrity enough to say he was willing, and it was definitely worth more than what I was asking. Because of that man’s integrity, I called him and said I’d be driving 100 miles to bring him those watches today still in Ohio. He informed me his staff may not be as well-versed in the watches, but he gave them a rundown and they dealt with me had a great conversation. I do not remember their names. I’m terrible with that, but those two that were in that shop yesterday were delight to speak with and to deal with on a business level in there Because of his integrity and the services I got I’ve never had nothing smoother or felt more comfortable doing a deal like that in establishing I’ve never been to it with people. I’ve never made a business relationship with. All that said every single time I need to bring something to liquidate along the lines of what they sell I will be more than happy to refer anybody to the shop or to bring them to it myself and look like they had some nice coins and jewelry in there to grab up I didn’t check the pricing on there, but I will next time, my man thank you guys for the great experience and I appreciate the professionalism and the integrity of character and makes that business stand out amongst all Others There’s a very few like you guys keep it up.
• DJ

  De'Ontray Johnson

  May 29, 2025
  5.0
  Easy, simple transaction for a good price.