Business Management ConsultantBusiness Development Service
Agency Brokerage Consultants is the leading expert on the valuation, sale, and acquisition of independent insurance agencies. We provide buyer and seller representation, as well as independent valuation services.
We'll be right by your side from the very beginning, whether that's scouting potential business opportunities or valuing your existing business. When it comes time to meet with potential candidates, we'll be right by your side, leading the negotiation, to push you through to closing.
A proud member of FAIA, LAAIA, IBBA, and M&A Source, we service insurance distribution businesses, including retail agencies, wholesale brokerages, MGAs, MGUs, and program administrators. Contact our certified business intermediaries to get started!
The support I received from Mike, Colby and the team at Agency Brokerage was invaluable. They were incredibly responsive, flexible and patient, as they were able to walk me through various scenarios, helping me understand different valuation approaches as well as strategies for achieving my goals. I would highly recommend them to a buyer or seller !
TH
Tom Hernan
Oct 7, 2025
5.0
Working with Colby at Agency Brokerage for Fractional CFO services has been a great experience. Each time we meet it's well a balanced conversation on short, medium, and long term goals to make sure I'm investing my time and attention as an agency principal where it matters most. He brings a wide but focused range of experience on agency performance, financials, and owner planning. Colby has quickly become a member of my leadership team.
JJ
James
Sep 21, 2024
5.0
Sean is always the consummate professional. He and his team are the best in the business! Highly recommend.
BA
Blair Ashton
Oct 24, 2022
5.0
What a team ABC has! From start to finish of selling my agency everyone was available for questions. Special thank you to Sean who spearheaded the whole acquisition. He worked extremely hard in finding the right buyers for my niche agency. Thank you to Caitlin for keeping everything organized and on task. Could not ask for a better team to handle the sale of my agency! Thank you guys so much with how flawless everything went. IF I ever buy/sell again you will be the first I call!
OG
Octavio Gallego
Sep 13, 2022
5.0
Lou and Sean are really good guys who kept the my best interest at heart. I am happy with the sale of my business and would recommend these guys to anyone!
Frequently Asked Questions About Agency Brokerage Consultants
Why should I use Agency Brokerage to value my agency?
We have multiple, certified business appraisers on staff. Our team has evaluated thousands of insurance agencies and brokerages and has been involved in hundreds of M&A transactions, giving us real insight into the marketplace. We are also the go-to valuation source for some of the industry’s top lenders.
How is the value of my insurance agency determined?
The value of an agency is based on a variety of factors including (1) the quality of the book of business, staff, and systems, (2) the size of the agency, (3) the agency’s organic growth rate, and (4) the pro forma EBITDA. The purpose of the valuation engagement often dictates financial adjustments and the methods that are used. Valuing the agency to determine market value is different from valuing for a shareholder buyout which is different from valuing for an ESOP, etc.
What steps can I take to prepare my insurance agency for sale?
The #1 thing you can do to prepare for the sale of your agency is to work with our team on a valuation of the agency. Through that process, we will be able to help you understand what you should focus on to maximize the value and prepare for your exit.
What is the typical timeframe for selling an insurance agency?
On average, it takes about 90 days to close the sale after going to market.
What is the #1 mistake that agency owners make when selling?
The biggest mistake that sellers make is selling directly to a buyer without going to market and without professional representation. On average, buyers pay 30% percent less for an acquisition by negotiating directly with the agency owner. The sale process typically also takes longer since the buyer controls the speed at which things move.